I'm shopping for a new roof and learning that there are a lot more choices for shingles these days. I've decided against using composite asphalt shingles. Natural slate and shake are out of the question for cost and safety reasons. I'm seriously considering synthetic slate or shake and like the colors and textures I've seen, but I'd sure appreciate your opinion.
darrell 6-19-07 12:26am
Synthetic slate and shake shingles - made from engineered polymers - have evolved dramatically. The newer generation looks so good that homeowners, architects and contractors need to squint to tell they're not the real thing. The shingles are high-tech and offer homeowners significant cost and maintenance savings. They look just like real quarried slate or cedar shake and come in a wide variety of colors, thicknesses, blends and widths.
Besides looks and longevity, they real advantage is cost savings. Compared to natural slate, synthetic is at least half the installed cost. Compared to good composite asphalt, you'll pay two to three times more for a typical installation, but they are also warranted to last two or three times longer.
The newest, best synthetic shingles don't curl, fade or crack. There's no treating required and no termites, silverfish or mold. They won't absorb water, so there are no freeze-thaw issues. Some manufacturers, like DaVinci Roofscapes , for example, specialize in synthetics and are so confident of the durability that they offer 50-year warranties.
When shopping synthetics, look for a thickness of at least ½ inch. This will deepen shadow lines and convey the look of premium shake or natural stone. Also check for multiple shingle widths, to create a non-repeating, distinctive and varied pattern.
The best synthetic shingles also provide advanced home safety and protection, including the highest fire rating (Class A), the highest impact rating (Class 4), and the highest ratings for wind resistance (110 mph). Actually, these can save homeowners money too - on insurance premiums.
Make sure the shingle has been tested byindependent organizations like United Laboratories (UL) or the ICC Evaluation Service. Verify that products meet certain standards like the International Building Code® (IBC), International Residential Code® (IRC) and the Uniform Building Code™ (UBC). UL can confirm the fire rating, impact rating and wind resistance.
Bottom line, don't be afraid to consider synthetic slate and shake shingles. They offer beauty, enhanced safety, hassle-free installation and some very attractive cost savings. Only you and the roofer need to know that it's not the real thing.
Reaching Tom: If you have a home improvement question or comment on this topic, please post it below. For answers to other home improvement questions, please email Tom at email@example.com  so your question can be used in future blog entries, or search Tom's home improvement articles at moneypit.com .